Sanctuary from the Mad World

ReviewReviewThe Painter of ShanghaiMay 4, '08 8:15 AM
for everyone
Category:Books
Genre: Literature & Fiction
Author:Jennifer Cody Epstein
I read the book's review in NYT and picked it up due to its intriguing story about a painter from Shanghai's golden era who used to be a prostitute. While it is a work of fiction, the story is based on the real life painter Pan Yu Liang who is famous for her beautiful nude paintings which combine both the western and chinese painting styles.

At 14 and orphaned, she was sold to a brothel by her uncle. She then attracted the attention of a wealthy official who made her his mistress. He also encouraged her to pursue her passion of painting. She defied the norm by winning a place to study art in the Shanghai Art School and won scholarships to Europe. She left China when her art was under attack for indecency: she painted nude women, western-style, and often used herself as a model.

I didn't expect much as I understand it's a no-brainer perfect for my beach holiday but the story is too superficial. While the description of her days in the brothel is horrifying, the central question posed on the book, can a prostitute escape her past (or something similar), was not answered in the end. The story went on and on about her angelic saviour, the wealthy government official, and the exotic whims of artists who suffered for his or her arts. The writer's padding of the already known facts was thin and typical. It is a pity, really, because Pan's life story is fascinating which may be better told in a form of biography.


13 CommentsChronological   Reverse   Threaded
esduren wrote on May 4
thanks for the review! it's always good to know which books deserve being read and possessed, and which do neither!

p.s. banner di atas ganti lagi ya.. keren!
tkmaia wrote on May 4, edited on May 4
Review
why do I get a feeling that a lot of westerners think chinese ladies are either mistresses or prostitutes... is it because the first story out was that play called madame butterfly.. wait but that was a guy and it was in japan !! But white people don't see this difference do they..hihi. Overly romanticized oriental life ya. Oriental ladies = sex! .. There must be other stories :D btw. I like your new pics up there! :). Hey how do i get the star out of my reply, i'll just pic one then....
bookshop wrote on May 4
esduren said
and which do neither
Hahahha.. iya.. ini yg penting :)).

PS: iya tuh.. Thanks! :D
bookshop wrote on May 4
tkmaia said
Overly romanticized oriental life ya. Oriental ladies = sex!
Exactly! This book, although written by a lady, has that flavour. Demure lady fated for a life of servitude but due to her strength (or her saviour) rose above all and beat the odds. Yeah.. yeah.. Stupid me, I always fall for such cheap trick.

PS: Madame Butterfly! Hahahha, you're hilarous!
makdemplon wrote on May 4
it's a no-brainer perfect for my beach holiday
haduh, ke mana??? *rindu pantai*
Sekarang di sini lagi banyak buku2 dari penulis/berbasis kisah oriental, tapi nggaktau mana yang bagus di baca, mana yang nggak. Apalagi waktu untuk membaca dikit banget, jengkel kalau 'terjebak' buku nggak asik...thanks ven!
yohanesb wrote on May 4
Alo Vennn.. wah, gua nunggu deh kapan ini masuk layar lebar aja deh hehe..
btw, beach holiday kemana neh?? lo ke French Riviera neh ceritanya hehe..
bookshop wrote on May 4
haduh, ke mana??? *rindu pantai*
Andalusia, Spanyol. Asik pantainya, kalo gak terlalu sebel dengan angin yg kencang.

Emang.. kayaknya cerita2 oriental lagi ngetrend. Cuma isinya rada basi: kalo gak soal cewek dan romance, soal hidup di bawah rezim komunis :p
bookshop wrote on May 4
gua nunggu deh kapan ini masuk layar lebar aja deh hehe..
Elo :)) Idih.. gak deh. Ke Andalusia aja, keliling2 sambil nyari pantai :D
chianiago wrote on May 5, edited on May 5
Berat nih bacaannya Ven =)
tapi covernya bagus...
yohanesb wrote on May 5
Ke Andalusia aja, keliling2 sambil nyari pantai :D
Wah bagus bgt neh Ven.. cultural spot bgt, en rich in culture.. Alhambra disini juga gak ya kalo gak salah? gua tunggu postingan lo ya :) gua gak jelas ini di daerah mana percis, tapi kalo Basque region gitu (utara ya?) byk teroris gitu.. ati2 lor.
bookshop wrote on May 5
Berat nih bacaannya Ven =)
Ini ringan banget kok (buku dan tulisannya :D). Iya, covernya bagus banget.
bookshop wrote on May 5
lhambra disini juga gak ya
iya, ke Alhambra memang tujuannya. Sip, ditunggu deh :D. Bener.. untuk sementara belon ke Basque :p
makdemplon wrote on May 5
Andalusia, Spanyol. Asik pantainya, kalo gak terlalu sebel dengan angin yg kencang.
Wow, Andalusia! Foto-fotonya dong... ;)
Bener ya stereotype, kali buat orang sini tema itu masih selling..apalagi covernya yang bagus-bagus ;)
Add a Comment
How would you rate this book? (optional)
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help